Argentina's Soy Planters Betting The Farm On The Trade War Outcome
Faced with a plunge in prices for their crops sparked by the US-China trade war, Argentine soy farmers have had little choice this year but to take the losses or hold onto their stocks in a bet on an eventual truce.
The local Rosario grains exchange estimates that despite a bumper harvest, the fall in soybean prices - at a decade low earlier this month - will knock $1.4 billion (€1.3 billion) off the country's expected soybean-related income this season.
Argentina, one of the world's top soy exporters, is in the middle of its soybean harvest, with exports of the oilseed key to helping the country climb out of a deep recession and bolster President Mauricio Macri ahead of national elections in October.
Sale prices for soy at the Rosario grains hub are now at $230 (€206.5) per tonne, down from around $280 (€251.3) in the middle of last year when farmers were starting to make plans for planting, according to prices on the Buenos Aires Futures and Options Exchange. They have bounced from a decade low of under $210 (€188.5) earlier in May.
Impact Of Falling Prices
"The impact of falling prices is huge," Lucas Elizalde, a farmer from the northern province of Salta, told Reuters, adding that lower margins were sapping much of farmers' profits.
Elizalde is one of the luckier ones. He sold 60% of his soybean crop on the futures market at as much as $300 per tonne before the price dropped.
"We got a good average sale price, but today I feel like 'dang, why did I not sell more?'"
Others have been holding onto their soy - with 60% remaining unsold as of 22 May, official data show, compared to 47% at the same time a year earlier.
Juan Minvielle, a producer from the north of Buenos Aires province, has seen his trade war bet backfire, despite good weather in the region and decent soybean yields. He had hoarded his soybeans, awaiting for a rebound in prices.
"Since the (earlier) corn harvest I've been living off that, but I don't have much left," said Minvielle.
"So now I'm starting to sell some soybeans, though trying to hold off for as long as I can."
The price has been hit by oversupply of soy in the United States due to the US-China trade war that has caused a glut of beans that would previously have traveled east.
China's culling of soy meal-fed hog herds due to swine flu has dampened prices, too.
Pull-Back In Demand
"There's been a strong pull-back in demand from the main global buyer of soybeans (China), which is creating an over-sold market," Agustín Tejeda, chief economic analyst at the Buenos Aires grain exchange, said in an interview.
Argentina is set for a major harvest in terms of volume after a drought last year hammered the crop. The Rosario exchange estimates the soybean harvest will hit 57 million tonnes, the third largest in the history of Argentina, the world's leading exporter of processed soy oil and meal.
Arnaldo Rearte, a farmer in the northeastern province of Chaco, said the lower prices had been brutal, compounding flooding which had hit the remote region during the harvest.
"We hope that the global conflict between the big shots won't cause us another fall next season," Rearte said.