Reality Bites For British Retail As Storm Clouds Gather: Gadfly
Reality is finally starting to bite for Britain's clothing and home furnishings retailers.
While there was plenty of commentary from Next, John Lewis and Wm Morrison Supermarkets that Britain's vote to leave the European Union was having little impact on spending, some of the results and outlook statements published Thursday were decidedly less rosy.
Until now, it's been a case of when the going gets tough, Brits go shopping, snapping up everything from off-the-shoulder dresses to flat screen TVs.
But the raft of results from some big retailers were more sobering, and might well provide a glimpse of what is to come. The grimmer news was underscored by official data showing U.K. sales dipped 0.2 percent in August from the previous month. Either way you look at it -- near term or longer term -- prospects aren't great for British shops.
H&M's August sales missed analysts' estimates while Next said that trading since July had been volatile and challenging. The John Lewis Partnership's profit fell a whopping 75 percent in the first half of its financial year. While that was mostly due to one off losses and investments, it also reflected a very price competitive market.
And non-food retailers also warned of challenges ahead. Next and John Lewis department stores flagged the prospect of higher prices for consumers next year -- the slump in sterling following the vote to leave the European Union raises the cost of buying dollar-denominated stock from Asia.
That's tricky for retailers, because thriftier consumers might not literally or metaphorically wear higher prices. John Lewis expects shops to absorb much of the increased sourcing costs. That's also the picture from Associated British Foods' Primark. Next, however, will try to pass the higher costs on to its customers, preferring to take the associated hit to sales than hurt its margins.
Next was also the first to warn of a wider impact from inflation: spending being squeezed next year by higher prices. That red flag is significant, because pressure on take-home pay was one of the factors that hurt retail sales during the most recent economic downturn.
But it's not just longer-term pressures that make the outlook so difficult.
The recent U.K. mini-heatwave is also putting consumers off from buying new coats or sweaters,which is bad news for the crucial autumn/winter fashion collections that have just started arriving in stores. Simon Wolfson, chief executive of Next, warned that the weather would have a "massive" impact on sales, and the longer the warm spell went on, the worst the impact would be.
And it may not just be the weather that is weighing on shoppers.
According to Richard Hyman, the independent retail analyst, there might be some Brexit impact from the higher cost of foreign travel for summer holidays. He estimates that weaker sterling added 500 million pounds ($661.9 billion) to the total cost of Britons' vacations. With those credit card bills now landing, that's money that's not being spent in shops.
Brexit's hit to summer holiday costs
Amid the brewing maelstrom Marks & Spencer looks vulnerable as clothes and home furnishings accounted for 37.5 percent of sales in its last financial year. And Britain's biggest clothing retailer by value is in the midst of a big drive to revive sales, so the hot spell could not have come at a worst time. The shares fell 2 percent on Thursday.
H&M, also faces an uphill battle. It's fighting a burst of consumer caution as well as nimbler rivals -- particularly Primark, which is simultaneously undercutting it while expanding internationally.
As for Next, where shares fell 4.6 percent on Thursday, it should be more resilient, thanks to its large online business, quality management and cash generation. It expects to generate 350 million pounds of surplus cash this year, giving it a cushion against trouble even as it uses some of it to boost business from its more-profitable credit customers.
That should all help it to weather the storm -- even one that involves plenty of sunshine.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.
News by Bloomberg, edited by ESM. To subscribe to ESM: The European Supermarket Magazine, click here.